The Uselessness of Critical Race Theory for the Christian Mind

On Critical Race Theory, conservatives keep getting caught up in the word game. Remember that it is a theoretical model for the interpretation of sociology (in particular, of legal functions).

It is either true or false, real or imaginary, before it gets to any data. We get confused as soon as statistics are raised that imply unjust applications of law based upon racial interests, or terminology about ‘races’, or the right interpretation of history and who can interpret it when really it’s just “critical” methodology applied to race in law.

It’s not really a big thing.

It’s not a persuasive position.

It’s not one readily defended by most folks of any inclination when they take the time to think about what is actually being said.

Now some will jump immediately to the fruit of its application, speaking to the actual problems in race, law, justice and history as validation for CRT but at that point CRT itself has become irrelevant to the discussion.

At that point we are just using the old tools of history, ethics and reason to make arguments toward certain preferred outcomes from certain existing conditions.

CRT is not helpful here particularly because if it’s method is carefully followed it can render rational moral discourse of the old kind that brought such powerful and meaningful progress into race based analysis moot. It is a philosophy, and that would lead us to ask, then is it good philosophy? And if it is not then why have it?

The best answer seems to be because of the confusion it causes when no one can figure out what it is.

And that is because people can get just about anything out of it.

As soon as someone says “critical race theory implies this… “ someone else will say it implies that, and another that it implies something else because it is made of wax and has little in the way of formal or solid foundations for its applications or interpretation. It could mean almost anything under the right torture and manipulation.

But some intend its use to divide people and take advantage of an opportunity to spoil the unity of the people of God. All over a little bit of color.

So we need to be on point Christian. We are one people, one nation that God has made a nation. The world might do it’s usual work of hate and division but as for us we will have none of it.

For the Christian God has made all people of the Earth of one blood and calls forth his own from every nation, people, tribe and tongue and our citizenship is of a far off country.

Neiswonger

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s